Tribunal Rules Nursing worker wrongly dismissed for expressing Christian Belief on Homosexuality

An employment tribunal in Watford ruled in favour of a Christian nursery worker who was fired after telling a co-worker her views against homosexuality.

The employment tribunal ruled that Sarah Mbuyi, a Belgian national and nursery worker from Tottenham, north London, should not have been dismissed by her employer as her actions were “worthy of respect in a democratic society.”

The 31-year-old Mbuyi filed a discrimination case against her ex-employer, west London-based Newpark Childcare, last April 2014 after she was dismissed in 2013.  The nursery school has a policy prohibiting employees from expressing adverse views on homosexuality and bars describing lesbians or gays as sinners.

Mbuyi came from Belgium 7 years ago and landed work with Newpark Childcare where she cared for children below one year of age. She was dismissed for gross misconduct when a colleague complained Mbuyi handed a Bible to her and told her, “God is not OK with what you do [but] everyone is a sinner and God offers forgiveness,” after she asked Mbuyi if God will approve her same-sex partnership.

Believing that her employer violated her right to freedom of religion protected under European law, Mbuyi decided to file a complaint for discrimination with the support of the Christian Legal Centre.

Newpark Childcare director Tiffany Clutterbuck said in a June 7 interview with The Sunday Times that the ruling was a disappointment, adding that they decided to dismiss Mbuyi in order to enforce their policies and protect a culture that promotes inclusiveness and support of all employees.

Andrea Minichiello Williams, the head of the Christian Legal Centre, told The Guardian last June 7 that the decision was a “brave judgment.”

Williams went on to say that the judgment showed “understanding of the Christian faith” and an employee’s right to “live and speak it out in the work place.”


Go Back to Previous Page